Experience
Finnegan wins major defense victory for Toyota
AutoConnect Holdings LLC
Toyota Motor Corporation et al.
Finnegan represented the Toyota entities in this patent infringement litigation brought by AutoConnect Holdings involving 11 patents directed to connected vehicle technology, including Toyota’s implementation of Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, as well as related inter partes review proceedings before the PTAB. AutoConnect sought significant damages in the district court litigation.
Finnegan developed a licensing defense after uncovering that the asserted patents had previously been assigned to a company affiliated with Erich Spangenberg. More than a decade earlier, Toyota had entered into a license agreement with Spangenberg granting Toyota a license to patents ever owned by a “Spangenberg Related Entity.” Finnegan argued that the agreement therefore licensed Toyota to the asserted patents and that the license continued to apply when the patents were later transferred to AutoConnect. The team developed the factual record supporting that defense and moved for summary judgment.
In July 2026, the magistrate judge issued a report and recommendation supporting Toyota’s summary judgment motion. On November 13, 2026, Judge Gilstrap overruled AutoConnect’s objections, granted summary judgment in Toyota’s favor based on the licensing defense, entered final judgment in Toyota’s favor, and awarded costs to Toyota, securing a complete defense victory and ending the significant district court case against Toyota.
AutoConnect Holdings LLC v. Toyota Motor Corporation et al., 2:24-cv-00802; 2:24-cv-00877, E.D. Tex., Judge Gilstrap
Toyota Motor Corporation et al. v. AutoConnect Holdings LLC, IPR2025-00890; IPR2025-00891, PTAB, Stewart
Intellectual Ventures I LLC et al. v. Toyota Motor Corp. et al.
Toyota Motor Corp. et al.
Toyota Motor Corp. v. Innovative Display Technologies, LLC
Toyota Motor Corporation
Innovative Display Techs. LLC v. Hyundai Motor Co.
Toyota Motor Corp.
Toyota Motor Corporation v. General Electric Co./GE Hybrid Technologies, LLC.
Toyota Motor Corporation
Clean sweep at the PTAB for SharkNinja
SharkNinja Operating LLC et al
Finnegan revives key Jublia® patent at the Federal Circuit
Kaken Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.; Bausch Health Care
Matrix Motors v. Toyota Motor Sales
Toyota Motor Sales
Due to international data regulations, we’ve updated our privacy policy. Click here to read our privacy policy in full.