直 Japanese PDF Font
  • Our Professionals
  • Our Work
  • Our Insights
  • Offices
  • Firm
  • Careers
Finnegan
  • News
  • Finnegan Facts
  • History
    • Finnegan VISION
    • Finnegan FORWARD
  • Pro Bono
  • Management
    • Pricing & Alternative Fee Arrangements
    • AFA Models We Offer
    • Contingency Fees
    • AI + KM

Commentary

New Thomas Pink Womenswear Lines Strain ‘Pink’ Pact with Victoria’s Secret

September 21, 2026

MLex

Victoria’s Secret and Thomas Pink are in a dispute over the scope of a 2015 trademark coexistence agreement that ended their earlier international litigation over the “PINK” mark. Victoria’s Secret argues that Thomas Pink’s use of new “PINK” marks for women’s casualwear and athleticwear sold through retailers including Fashion Nova, Charlotte Russe, and Rue21 falls outside the business contemplated by the agreement.  

Thomas Pink maintains that the agreement does not impose an express product-category restriction and has asked the Ohio federal court to dismiss or stay the case based on a provision requiring disputes to be submitted to English courts. 

Speaking to MLex, Finnegan Of Counsel Jenevieve Maerker said parties often prefer to reserve questions about future expansion rather than accept rigid restrictions from the outset. 

“It’s much easier for parties to agree to kick some disputes down the road,” she said.  “They don’t know how their businesses are going to evolve, and so they’re just going to reserve their rights.” 

The parties also dispute the significance of separate consent-to-registration agreements executed in 2024 and 2026 for particular U.S. trademark applications, including one covering women’s clothing. Thomas Pink cites those agreements as evidence that Victoria’s Secret accepted continued coexistence, while Victoria’s Secret maintains that the consents involved different stylized marks and that it did not know Thomas Pink intended to use PINK on women’s products that would directly compete with its own. Addressing consent agreements generally, Jenevieve suggests trademark owners closely examine applications covering products or services in close proximity to their own before granting consent. 

“If you’re looking at an application that covers goods that are relevant, that are closer than you would want them to be to your goods, dig into that in the context of negotiating that consent agreement,” she added. 

Related proceedings are also underway in the UK, where the High Court has been asked to address the parties’ rights under the 2015 agreement and whether Victoria’s Secret breached the settlement by filing its Ohio action.  

Jenevieve said whatever the High Court decides, she views the case as a good reminder to trademark owners on the need to draft for commercial change and keep testing the assumptions built into a coexistence agreement. “You have to really work hard to be future-thinking and future-proof,” she explained, “and you have to continue to monitor.” 

“When one party decides that they want to shift their focus, that’s when you run into trouble,” she added. 

Read "New Thomas Pink Womenswear Lines Strain ‘Pink’ Pact with Victoria’s Secret" 

Related Practices

Global IP Enforcement, Litigation, and Trials

Trademark Litigation and Trials

Trademark and Brand Management

Trademark Oppositions and Cancellations

Trademark Counseling and Prosecution

Related Industries

Consumer Goods and Services

Consumer Products

Related Offices

Boston, MA

Related Professionals

Jenevieve J. Maerker
Of Counsel
Boston, MA
+1 617 646 1655
Email

Related News

Commentary

My Chemical Romance Folds to Cowboys Cheerleaders with Law Murky

November 6, 2026

Commentary

Hair Suit: Erling Haaland and the Limits of Real-Time Marketing

November 5, 2026

Commentary

Oura Targets Ultrahuman’s Redesigned Smart Ring Following Import Ban

October 29, 2026

Commentary

Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Sue My Chemical Romance

October 29, 2026

Commentary

Grey Areas Haunt Victoria’s Secret ‘Pink’ Coexistence Pact

October 23, 2026

Award/Ranking

Finnegan Shortlisted for Two ALB Korea Law Awards 2026

October 23, 2026

Award/Ranking

Six Finnegan Partners Named to IAM 2027 Global Leaders Guide

October 21, 2026

Commentary

Finnegan Betting on Investments in Becoming Global One-Stop IP Shop

October 12, 2026

Award/Ranking

Finnegan Recognized Again Among Germany’s Leading Law Firms

October 9, 2026

Due to international data regulations, we’ve updated our privacy policy. Click here to read our privacy policy in full.

  • Privacy
  • Disclaimer
  • Legal Notices
  • Fraud Alert
  • EEO Statement
  • Cookies
  • Contact Us

© 2026 Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP