直 Japanese PDF Font
  • Our Professionals
  • Our Work
  • Our Insights
  • Offices
  • Firm
  • Careers
Finnegan
  • Articles & Books
    • Ad Law Buzz Blog
    • At the PTAB Blog
    • European IP Blog
    • Federal Circuit IP Blog
    • INCONTESTABLE® Blog
    • Prosecution First Blog
  • Events & Webinars
  • IP Updates
  • Podcasts
    • AI + Finnegan
    • AI + Copyright
    • AI + Patent
    • AI + Privacy
    • AI + Trade Secrets
    • AI + Trademark
  • Unified Patent Court (UPC) Hub

At the PTAB Blog

Back to the Board: Director Squires Returns Merits-Based Institution Decisions to PTAB Panels

November 20, 2026

Authored and Edited by Jaide L. Cummings; William C. Neer; Forrest A. Jones

Director John Squires’ most recent Memorandum, Returning Merits-Based Considerations to PTAB, restores Administrative Patent Judges’ role in reviewing the merits of IPR and PGR petitions while preserving the Director’s role in reviewing discretionary denial considerations.

Since Director Squires assumed control of the bifurcated institution process last year, he has reviewed both discretionary and non-discretionary considerations when deciding whether to institute an AIA trial. True to its title, in the Returning Merits-Based Considerations to PTAB Memorandum, Director Squires has relinquished control over the second half of the bifurcated institution process by returning the responsibility for reviewing merits and non-discretionary considerations to the PTAB. In particular, any petition that the Director does not discretionarily deny will be reviewed by a panel of three Administrative Patent Judges. The Memorandum provides five guidelines for the PTAB to apply when analyzing merits and non-discretionary considerations:  

  1. The PTAB will deny institution if the petition does not demonstrate how the prior art discloses or renders obvious each limitation of the challenged claims, or provide an understandable, element-by-element explanation of the patentability challenges;

  2. The PTAB will deny institution if the petition fails to show that a “substantial majority of challenged claims” meet the institution threshold;

  3. The PTAB will deny institution if the patent owner raises a “reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence” that the petitioner failed to meet the substantial majority standard;

  4. The PTAB will deny institution if it determines that a “reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence, shows that the petitioner” failed to meet the substantial majority standard; or

  5. The PTAB will deny institution if the parties’ “evidence and arguments are in equipoise” for a particular challenged claim because the petitioner has not met the IPR “reasonable likelihood” standard or the “more likely than not” PGR standard.

The PTAB panel will issue an institution decision that “briefly address[es] the merits-based considerations that the panel found important” and “set[s] forth sufficient information showing that the petitioner has or has not met the appropriate standard at least as to one claim and one ground asserted in the petition.” The Memorandum also establishes that if the PTAB panel institutes a petition, the Office will assign a completely new panel of judges to conduct the trial.

Tags

United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), discretionary denials

Related Practices

Patent Office Invalidation Proceedings

PTAB Invalidation Proceedings: IPR and PGR

Related Offices

Washington, DC

Contacts

Jaide L. Cummings
Law Clerk
Washington, DC
+1 202 408 4056
Email
William C. Neer
Associate
Washington, DC
+1 202 408 4054
Email
Forrest A. Jones
Partner
Washington, DC
+1 202 408 4019
Email

Copyright © 2026 Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP. 

DISCLAIMER: Although we wish to hear from you, information exchanged in this blog cannot and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not post any information that you consider to be personal or confidential. If you wish for Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP to consider representing you, in order to establish an attorney-client relationship you must first enter a written representation agreement with Finnegan. Contact us for additional information. One of our lawyers will be happy to discuss the possibility of representation with you. Additional disclaimer information.

Related Insights

Conference

2027 ABA-IPL Section Annual Meeting – IPLSPRING

April 14-15, 2027

Arlington

Conference

Patent Litigation Europe 2027

January 18-20, 2027

Amsterdam

Seminar

Global Innovation Index: Perspectives on IP and Innovation Ecosystems

December 14, 2026

Washington, DC

Seminar

Global Patent Strategies for Life Sciences and Chemical Innovations: Key Developments in Europe and the United States – Osaka

December 10, 2026

Osaka

Webinar

Trade Secret Laws and Sausages: A Look at Efforts to Update the UTSA

December 10, 2026

Webinar

Seminar

Global Patent Strategies for Life Sciences and Chemical Innovations: Key Developments in Europe and the United States – Tokyo

December 8, 2026

Tokyo

Conference

Licensing Executives Society Chinese Taipei – Annual Conference 2026

December 4, 2026

Taipei

Panel Discussion

2026 Advanced Patent Law Institute

December 3-4, 2026

Stanford

Conference

WTR Live: Brand Strategy Summit Asia 2026

December 2-3, 2026

Pickering

Due to international data regulations, we’ve updated our privacy policy. Click here to read our privacy policy in full.

  • Privacy
  • Disclaimer
  • Legal Notices
  • Fraud Alert
  • EEO Statement
  • Cookies
  • Contact Us

© 2026 Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP