AIA BLOG
IPR FWD - Appealed
As the body of case law develops around AIA PTAB trials, Final Written Decisions (FWDs) that have been considered on appeal will be instructive for developing case strategies. Inter partes review cases for which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) has rendered a decision are listed below with links to the FWD and the CAFC decision. For decisions that Finnegan has summarized for the Federal Circuit IP Blog, the PTAB case name is linked to the summary.
|
PTAB Case Name |
PTAB Case Number(s) |
FWD Date |
CAFC Case Number(s) |
CAFC Decision Date |
CAFC Decision |
Rule 36 |
|
Zhongshan Broad Ocean Motor Co., Ltd., Broad Ocean Motor LLC, Broad Ocean Technologies, LLC v. Nidec Motor Corp. |
5/9/2016 |
8/22/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Diablo Technologies, Inc. v. Netlist, Inc. |
12/14/2015 |
7/25/2017 |
Vacated, Remanded |
No |
||
|
VTech Communications, Inc.; Uniden America Corp. v. Spherix Inc. |
2/3/2016 |
7/25/2017 |
Reversed |
No |
||
|
Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.; Samsung Electronics America, Inc.; Samsung Semiconductor, Inc.; Samsung Austin Semiconductor LLC v. Home Semiconductor Corp. |
4/20/2016 |
7/25/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Gordon * Howard Associates, Inc. v. LunarEye, Inc. |
9/28/2015 2/2/2016 |
7/24/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
HTC Corp., HTC America, ZTE (USA), Inc., Pantech Co., Ltd., Pantech Wireless, Inc., LG Electronics, Inc., LG Electronics U.S.A., Inc. v. Cellular Communications Equipment, LLC |
1/4/2017 |
7/17/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Google Inc. v. Intellectual Ventures II LLC |
11/20/2015 |
7/10/17 |
Affirmed in part, Vacated, Remanded in part |
No |
||
|
Alliance of Rare-Earth Permanent Magnet Industry v. Hitachi Metals, Ltd. |
2/8/2016 |
16-1824 16-1825 |
7/6/2017 |
Affirmed in part, Vacated-in-part, Remanded |
No |
|
|
Securus Technologies, Inc. v. Global Tel*Link Corp. |
4/7/2016 |
7/4/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Securus Technologies, Inc. v. Gobal Tel*Link Corp. |
4/29/2016 |
6/19/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
VSR Industries, Inc. v. Cole Kepro International, LLC |
4/28/2016 |
6/19/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Ericsson Inc., Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v. Intellectual Ventures II LLC |
1/21/2016 |
6/19/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
GEOX S.p.A. v. Outdry Technologies Corp. |
12/18/2015 |
6/16/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. v. Emerachem Holdings, LLC |
1/22/2016 |
6/15/2017 |
Affirmed in part; vacated in part; remanded |
No |
||
|
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Samsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung Semiconductor, Inc., Samsung Austin Semiconductor LLC v. Home Semiconductor Corp. |
4/14/2016 |
6/14/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Xilinx, Inc. v. PLL Technologies, Inc. |
4/18/2016 |
6/13/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
HTC Corp., ZTE (USA), Amazon.com, Inc., Pantech Co., Ltd., Pantech Wireless, Inc., Dell Inc., LG Electronics, Inc., LG Electronics U.S.A., Inc. v. Cellular Communications Equipment LLC |
1/4/2016 |
6/9/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Coleman Cable, LLC, Jia Wei Technology (HK) Ltd., Jia Wei Technology (USA) Ltd., Shenzhen Jia Wei Photovoltaic Lighting Co, Ltd., Atico International (Asia) Ltd., Atico International USA, Inc., Smart Solar, Inc., Test Rite Products Corp. v. Simon Nicholas Richmond |
12/21/2015 |
6/9/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Mindgeek S.A.R.L., Mindgeek USA, Inc., Playboy Enterprises, Inc. v. Skky Inc. |
1/29/2016 |
6/7/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Oracle Corp., Netapp Inc. v. Crossroads Systems, Inc. |
1/29/2016 |
6/6/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Cisco Systems, Inc., Quantum Corp., Oracle Corp. v. Crossroads Systems, Inc. Cisco Systems, Inc. Oracle Corp. v. Crossroads Systems, Inc. Cisco Systems, Inc., Quantum Corp., Oracle Corp., Dot Hill Systems Corp. v. Crossroads Systems, Inc. |
IPR2014-01463 |
3/16/2016 1/29/2016 9/15/2015 1/29/2016 |
6/6/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
|
|
Motorola Mobility LLC v. Intellectual Ventures II LLC |
9/9/2015 |
5/31/2017 |
Vacated; remanded |
No |
||
|
Medtronic, Inc. v. Nuvasive, Inc. |
4/5/2015 |
5/31/2017 |
Vacated; remanded |
No |
||
|
Toshiba Corp. v. Optical Devices, LLC |
3/9/2016 |
5/15/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Epson America, Inc. v. Cascades Projection LLC |
11/29/2016 1/11/2017 |
5/11/2017 |
En banc petition denied |
No |
||
|
Bohler-Edelstahl GmbH & Co. KG v. Rovalma, S.A. |
4/20/2017 |
5/11/2017 |
Vacated, remanded |
No |
||
|
FedEx Corp. v. IP Venture, Inc. |
11/20/2015 |
5/9/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Enovate Medical, LLC v. Intermetro Industries Corp. |
5/11/2016 |
5/9/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Nestle USA, Inc. v. Steuben Foods, Inc. |
12/21/2015 |
5/9/2017 |
Remanded |
No |
||
|
Hyundai Mobis Co., Ltd., Mobis Alabama, L.L.C.v. Autoliv ASP, Inc. |
1/6/2016 |
4/24/2017 |
Reversed |
No |
||
|
ZTE Corp., ZTE (USA) Inc., Microsoft Corp. v. IPR Licensing, Inc. |
9/14/2014 |
16-1374 16-1443 |
4/20/2017 |
Affirmed in part, Vacated in part, Remanded |
No |
|
|
Medtronic, Inc. v. Nuvasive, Inc. |
4/3/15 9/14/14 |
4/20/2017 |
Affirmed in part; vacated in part; remanded |
No |
||
|
Noven Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc. v. Novartis AG and LTS Lohmann Therapie-Systeme AG |
9/28/2015 |
4/20/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Continental Automotive Systems, Inc. v. Wasica Finance GmbH & Bluearc Finance AG Schrader-Bridgeport International Sensata Technologies Holding N.V. and SI International (TOPCO), Inc. v. Wasica Finance GmbH & Bluearc Finance AG |
6/17/2015 7/22/2015 |
4/20/2017 |
Affirmed in part; reversed in part |
No |
||
|
Tech 21 UK Ltd. v. ZAGG Intellectual Property Holding Co., Inc. |
1/27/2016 |
4/11/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Motorola Mobility LLC v. Intellectual Ventures I LLC |
9/9/2015 |
3/20/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Zhongshan Broad Ocean Motor Co., Ltd., Broad Ocean Motor LLC, Broad Ocean Technologies, LLC v. Nidec Motor Corp. |
1/12/2016 |
3/14/2017 |
Reversed |
No |
||
|
Tietex International, Ltd. v. Precision Fabrics Group, Inc. |
1/27/2016 |
3/10/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Ford Motor Co. v. Paice LLC & The Abell Foundation, Inc. |
9/28/2015 |
3/7/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Hyundai Mobis Co., Ltd., Mobis Alabama, LLC |
1/6/2016 |
3/7/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
L-3 Communications Holdings, Inc., Premier Utility Services, LLC v. Power Survey, LLC |
11/23/2015 |
3/7/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Ford Motor Co. v. Paice LLC & The Abell Foundation, Inc. |
11/23/2015 |
3/7/2017 |
Affirmed in part, vacated in part, remanded |
No |
||
|
Google Inc. v. Michael Meiresonne |
1/20/2016 |
3/7/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Eli Lilly and Co. v. Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center |
10/22/2015 |
2/28/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Eli Lilly and Co. v. Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center |
10/22/2015 |
2/28/2017 |
Vacated and Remanded |
No |
||
|
Apple, Inc. v. Personal Web Technologies, LLC, Level 3 Communications, LLC |
3/25/2015 |
2/24/2017 |
Remanded |
No |
||
|
Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Depomed, Inc. |
9/16/2015 |
2/21/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
EMC Corp., RSA Security LLC v. Secure Axcess, LLC |
9/8/2015 |
2/21/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Apple Inc. v. THX Ltd. |
6/9/2015 |
2/17/2017 |
Affirmed-in-part; reversed-in-part |
No |
||
|
Ricoh Americas Corp., Xerox Corp., Lexmark International, Inc. v. MPHJ Technology Investments, LLC |
8/12/2015 |
2/13/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Qualtrics, LLC v. Opinionlab, Inc. |
7/30/2015 |
2/13/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
AVX Corp., AVX Filters Corp. v. Greatbatch, Ltd. |
10/21/2015 |
2/9/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
The Gillette Co., Fujitsu Semiconductor Ltd., Fujitsu Semiconductor America, Inc. v. Zond, LLC Fujitsu Semiconductor Ltd., Fujitsu Semiconductor America, Inc., Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., Renesas Electronics Corp., Renesas Electronics America, Inc., Globalfoundries U.S., Inc., Globalfoundries Dresden Module One LLC & Co. KG, Global Foundries Dresden Module Two LLC & Co. KG, Toshiba America Electronic Components, Inc., Toshiba America Inc., Toshiba America Information Systems, Inc., Toshiba Corp., The Gillette Co. v. Zond, LLC |
IPR2014-00580 |
10/1/2015 9/29/2015 10/2/2015 |
1/18/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
|
|
The Gillette Co. v. Zond, LLC The Gillette Co., Fujitsu Semiconductor Ltd., Fujitsu Semiconductor America, Inc., Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., Renesas Electronics Corp., Rensas Electronics America, Inc., Global Foundries U.S. Inc., Globalfoundries U.S., Inc., Globalfoundries Dresden Module One LLC & Co. KG, Global Foundries Dresden Module Two LLC & Co. KG, Toshiba America Electronic Components, Inc., Toshiba America Inc., Toshiba America Information Systems, Inc., Toshiba Corp. v. Zond, LLC |
IPR2014-00477 IPR2014-00479 IPR2014-00799 IPR2014-00803 IPR2014-00855 IPR2014-00858 IPR2014-00995 IPR2014-00996 IPR2014-01042 IPR2014-01061 |
9/4/2015 9/30/2015 |
1/18/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
|
|
Digital Ally, Inc. v. Utility Associates, Inc. |
11/16/2015 |
1/13/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Digital Ally, Inc. v. Utility Associates, Inc. |
11/16/2015 |
1/13/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
FLIR Systems, Inc. v. Leak Surveys, Inc. |
9/3/2015 |
1/10/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Phigenix, Inc. v. Immunogen, Inc. |
10/27/2015 |
1/9/2017 |
Dismissed |
No |
||
|
Broadcom Corp. v. Wi-Fi One, LLC |
6/1/2015 3/6/2015 |
1/4/2017 |
En banc granted |
No |
||
|
Eastman Kodak Co., AGFA Corp., ESKO Software BVBA, Heidelberg, USA v. CTP Innovations, LLC |
11/25/2015 |
12/21/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
NHK Seating of America, Inc. v. Lear Corp. |
12/30/2015 1/12/2016 1/5/2016 2/2/2016 |
12/20/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Johnson Controls, Inc. v. Wildcat Licensing WI, LLC |
6/22/2014 6/22/2015 |
12/20/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
NHK Seating of America, Inc. v. Lear Corp. |
12/30/2015 1/12/2016 1/5/2016 2/2/2016 |
12/20/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
LG Chem, Ltd. v. Celgard, LLC |
10/5/2015 |
12/13/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Compass Bank, Commerce Bancshares, Inc., First National Bank of Omaha v. Intellectual Ventures II, LLC |
9/23/2015 |
12/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Webasto Roof Systems, Inc. v. UUSI, LLC |
10/13/2015 |
12/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Motorola Mobility LLC v. Intellectual Ventures I LLC |
9/9/2015 |
12/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Apple Inc. v. VirnetX Inc. |
5/11/2015 |
12/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Apple Inc. v. VirnetX Inc. |
7/29/2015 8/24/2015 |
12/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Global Tel*Link Corp. v. Securus Technologies, Inc. |
9/11/2015 |
12/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
CSP Technologies, Inc. v. Clariant Corp. |
6/10/2015 |
12/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Medtronic, Inc. v. Nuvasive, Inc. |
2/11/2015 |
12/7/2016 |
Vacated; Remanded |
No |
||
|
Google Inc., Samsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Micrografx, LLC |
7/31/2015 |
11/29/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Google Inc., Samsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. v. Micrografx, LLC |
6/17/2015 |
11/29/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Facebook, Inc., Google, Inc., Match.com LLC, People Media, Inc. v. B.E. Technology, L.L.C. |
IPR2014-00052 |
3/31/2015 |
11/17/2016 |
Affirmed-in-part Dismissed-in-part |
No |
|
|
Oracle Corp., Oracle OTC Subsidiary LLC, YP Interactive LLC, Yellowpages.com LLC v. Click-To-Call Technologies LP |
10/28/2014 |
11/17/2016 |
Dismissed |
No |
||
|
Olympus America Inc., Olympus Medical Systems Corp. v. Perfect Surgical Techniques, Inc. |
6/8/2015 |
11/15/2016 |
Vacated; Remanded |
No |
||
|
Google Inc. v. Unwired Planet, LLC |
3/30/2015 |
11/15/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
SDI Technologies, Inc. v. Bose Corp. |
11/7/2014 |
11/14/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
U.S. Endoscopy Group, Inc. v. CDX Diagnostics, Inc. |
10/15/2015 |
11/14/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Medtronic, Inc. v. NuVasive, Inc. |
2/11/2015 |
11/9/2016 |
Affirmed-In-Part; Vacated-In-Part; Remanded |
No |
||
|
Churchill Drilling Tools US, Inc. v. Schoeller-Bleckmann Oilfield Equipment AG |
10/9/2015 |
11/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Amneal Pharmaceuticals LLC v. Endo Pharmaceuticals Inc. |
7/22/2015 |
11/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Neste Oil Oyj v. Reg Synthetic Fuels, LLC |
3/12/2015 |
11/8/2016 |
Affirmed-in-part Vacated-in-part Remanded |
No |
||
|
Stats LLC v. Hockeyline, Inc. |
9/15/2015 |
11/4/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Medtronic, Inc. v. Robert Bosch Healthcare Systems, Inc. |
5/22/2015 |
10/20/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Mexichem Amanco Holdings S.A. de C.V. v. Honeywell International, Inc. |
2/26/2015 |
10/11/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Mentor Graphics Corp. v. Synopsys, Inc. |
6/11/2015 |
10/11/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Juniper Networks, Inc. v. Brixham Solutions Ltd. |
7/27/2015 |
10/6/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Juniper Networks, Inc. v. Brixham Solutions, Ltd. |
7/27/2015 |
10/6/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Athena Automation Ltd. v. Husky Injection Molding Systems Ltd. |
10/23/2014 |
9/23/2016 |
Vacated; Remanded |
No |
||
|
Broadcom Corp. v. WI-FI One, LLC |
6/1/2015 |
9/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Broadcom Corp. v. WI-FI One, LLC |
3/6/2015 |
9/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Broadcom Corp. v. WI-FI ONE, LLC |
3/6/2015 |
9/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Facebook, Inc., LinkedIn Corp., Twitter, Inc. v. Software Rights Archive, LLC |
2/2/2015 1/29/2015 1/29/2015 |
9/9/2016 |
Affirmed in part; reversed in part |
No |
||
|
Veeam Software Corp. v. Symantec Corp. |
4/23/2015 |
8/30/2016 |
Affirmed, Vacated, Remanded |
No |
||
|
Customplay, LLC v. Clearplay, Inc. |
7/21/2015 |
8/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Ericsson Inc. v. Intellectual Ventures I LLC |
5/18/2015 |
8/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Apotex Inc. v. Wyeth LLC |
4/20/2015 |
8/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Zodiac Pool Systems, Inc. v. Aqua Products, Inc. |
8/22/2014 |
8/12/2016 |
En banc petition granted |
No |
||
|
Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc. v. B.E. Technology, L.L.C.; Google, Inc. v. B.E. Technology, L.L.C.; Microsoft Corp. v. B.E. Technology, L.L.C.; Samsung Electronics America, Inc. v. B.E. Technology, LLC |
IPR2014-00029 |
4/6/2015 4/6/2015 4/6/2015 4/6/2015 |
8/12/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
|
|
Apple Inc., Google Inc., Motorola Mobility LLC v. Arendi S.A.R.L. |
6/9/2015 |
8/10/2016 |
Reversed |
No |
||
|
Biodelivery Sciences International, Inc. v. RB Pharmaceuticals Ltd. |
6/30/2015 |
8/10/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Dell Inc., Hewlett-Packard Co., Netapp, Inc. v. Electronics and Telecommunications Research Institute |
2/27/2015 |
8/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Seoul Semiconductor Co., Ltd. and North America Seoul Semiconductor, Inc. v. Enplas Corp. |
9/11/2015 |
8/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Nuvasive, Inc. v. Warsaw Orthopedic, Inc. |
7/10/2014 |
8/9/2016 |
Affirmed in part; Vacated in part; Remanded |
No |
||
|
Conopco, Inc. dba Unilever v. The Procter & Gamble Co. |
2/10/2015 |
8/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Respironics, Inc. v. Zoll Medical Corp. |
9/17/2014 |
7/29/2016 |
Vacated; Remanded |
No |
||
|
McClinton Energy Group, LLC v. Magnum Oil Tools International, Ltd. |
9/2/2014 |
7/25/2016 |
Reversed |
No |
||
|
Apple, Inc., Google Inc., Motorola Mobility LLC v. Arrendi S.A.R.L. |
6/9/2015 |
15-2069 |
7/11/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
|
|
Covidien LP v. Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. |
6/9/2014 |
6/22/2016 |
Denied |
No |
||
|
Laird Technologies, Inc. v. GrafTech International Holdings, Inc. |
3/25/2015 |
6/17/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
BioMarin Pharmaceutical Inc. v. Genzyme Therapeutic Products Limited Partnership |
2/23/2015 |
6/14/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Toshiba Samsung Storage Technology Korea Corp. v. LG Electronics, Inc. |
4/1/2015 |
6/13/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Toshiba Samsung Storage Technology Korea Corp. v. LG Electronics, Inc. |
3/31/2015 |
6/13/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
SAS Institute, Inc. v. Complementsoft, LLC |
8/6/2014 |
6/10/2016 |
Affirmed; Remanded |
No |
||
|
Medtronic, Inc., Medtronic Vascular, Inc. v. Lifeport Sciences LLC |
4/21/2015 |
6/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Zodiac Pool Systems, Inc. v. Aqua Products, Inc. |
8/22/2014 |
5/25/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Unified Patents, Inc., SAP America, Inc. v. Clouding IP, LLC |
3/19/2015 |
5/19/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Facebook, Inc., LinkedIn Corp., Twitter, Inc. v. Software Rights Archive, LLC |
2/2/2015 |
5/17/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Nintendo of America Inc. v. Motion Games, LLC |
5/15/2015 |
5/10/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Medtronic, Inc., Medtronic Vascular, Inc., Medtronic Corevalve, LLC v. Troy R. Norred, M.D. |
4/23/2015 4/23/2015 6/25/2015 |
5/10/2016 |
Affirmed; Dismissed as moot |
No |
||
|
Nintendo of America Inc. v. Motion Games, LLC |
5/15/2015 |
5/10/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Samsung Electronics America, Inc., HTC Corp., HTC America, Inc. v. Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC |
5/13/2015 |
5/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Endotach LLC v. Medtronic, Inc., Medtronic Vascular, Inc. |
3/24/2015 |
5/6/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Johnson Health Tech Co., Ltd., Johnson Health Tech North America, Inc. v. ICON Health & Fitness, Inc. |
6/5/2015 |
5/5/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Greene’s Energy Group, LLC v. Oil States Energy Services, LLC |
12/3/2013 |
5/4/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Reloaded Games, Inc. v. Parallel Networks, LLC |
11/11/2013 |
5/4/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Square, Inc. v. J. Carl Cooper |
5/8/2015 5/14/2015 |
4/14/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Guangdong Xinbao Electrical Appliances Holdings Co., Ltd. v. Adrian Rivera |
10/9/2013 |
4/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
MotivePower, Inc. v. Cutsforth, Inc. |
5/6/2013 |
4/6/2016 |
Reversed |
No |
||
|
Hewlett-Packard Co. v. MPHJ Technology Investments, LLC |
11/19/2014 |
4/5/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Google Inc. v. Grandeye, Ltd. |
11/25/2014 |
3/28/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
International Securities Exchange, LLC v. Chicago Board Options Exchange, Inc. |
3/2/2015 |
3/25/2016 |
Vacated, Dismissed |
No |
||
|
Purdue Pharma L.P. v. Depomed, Inc. |
7/8/2015 |
3/24/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Shaw Industries Group, Inc. v. Automated Creel Systems, Inc. |
7/24/2014 |
3/23/2016 |
Affirmed-In-Part Vacated-In-Part Remanded-In-Part |
No |
||
|
Toyota Motor Corp. v. Leroy G. Hagenbuch |
12/5/2014 3/3/2015 3/3/2015 |
3/21/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
ACCO Brands Corp. v. Fellowes, Inc. |
2/12/2015 |
3/16/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Dell, Inc. v. Acceleron, LLC |
12/22/2014 |
3/15/2016 |
Affirmed Vacated Remanded |
No |
||
|
Honeywell International Inc. v. International Controls and Measurements Corp. |
4/1/2015 |
3/14/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Harmonic, Inc. v. Avid Technology, Inc. |
7/10/2014 |
3/1/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Corning Gilbert v. PPC Broadband, Inc. |
11/21/2014 |
2/22/2016 |
Vacated Remanded |
No |
||
|
Corning Gilbert v. PPC Broadband, Inc. |
11/21/2014 |
2/22/2016 |
Vacated Affirmed Remanded |
No |
||
|
Adidas AG v. Nike, Inc. |
04/28/2014 |
2/11/2016 |
Affirmed-In-Part Vacated-In-Part Remanded-In-Part |
No |
||
|
Silicon Motion Technology Corp. v. Phison Electronics Corp. |
1/28/2015 |
2/11/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Butamax Advanced Biofuels LLC v. Gevo, Inc. |
9/23/2014 |
2/10/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Synopsys, Inc. v. Mentor Graphics Corporation |
02/19/2014 |
2/10/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
International Business Machines Corporation v. Intellectual Ventures II LLC |
4/3/2015 |
2/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Tandus Flooring, Inc. v. Interface, Inc. |
12/8/2014 |
2/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
DeLaval International AB v. Lely Patent NV |
2/20/2015 |
2/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Ariosa Diagnostics, Inc. v. Board of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior University |
11/19/2014 |
2/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Trivascular, Inc. v. Shaun L. W. Samuels |
12/03/2014 |
2/5/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Intelligent Bio-Systems, Inc. v. Illumina Cambridge Ltd. |
10/28/2014 |
1/29/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Motivepower, Inc. v. Cutsforth, Inc. |
10/30/2014 |
1/22/2016 |
Vacated and Remanded |
No |
||
|
Pharmatech Solutions, Inc. v. LifeScan Scotland, Ltd., LifeScan, Inc. |
8/6/2014 |
1/20/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Rackspace Hosting, Inc. v. Clouding Corp., Clouding IP, LLC |
1/29/2015 |
1/15/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Covidien LP v. Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. |
6/9/2014 |
1/13/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Hayward Industries, Inc., v. Pentair Water Pool and Spa, Inc. |
11/19/2014 |
1/11/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Redline Detection, LLC v. Star EnviroTech, Inc. |
6/30/2014 |
12/31/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Motivepower, Inc. v. Cutsforth, Inc. |
10/30/2014 |
12/17/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Vibrant Media, Inc. v. General Electric Co. |
6/26/2014 |
12/17/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Gnosis S.p.A., Gnosis Bioresearch S.A., Gnosis U.S.A., Inc. v. Merck & Cie |
6/20/2014 |
12/17/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Gnosis S.p.A., Gnosis Bioresearch S.A., Gnosis U.S.A., Inc. v. South Alabama Medical Science Foundation |
6/20/2014 |
12/17/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Game Show Network, LLC and WorldWinner.com, Inc. v. John H Stephenson |
11/7/2014 |
12/15/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Polaris Wireless, Inc. v. TruePosition, Inc. |
11/3/2014 |
12/15/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Yissum Research Development Company of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem v. Sony Corp. |
11/6/2014 |
12/11/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Prolitec, Inc. v. ScentAir Technologies, Inc. |
6/26/2014 |
12/4/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Hewlett-Packard Company v. MCM Portfolio LLC |
8/6/2014 |
12/2/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
MCM Portfolio LLC v. Hewlett-Packard Company |
8/6/2014 |
12/2/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Sipnet EU S.R.O. v. Straight Path IP Group, Inc. |
10/9/2014 |
11/25/2015 |
Reversed and Remanded |
No |
||
|
Ariosa Diagnostics v. Verinata Health, Inc. |
10/23/2014 |
11/16/2015 |
Vacated and Remanded |
No |
||
|
The Scotts Company LLC v. Encap, LLC |
6/24/2014 |
11/12/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
*Oracle Corporation v. Click-to-Call Technologies, LP |
10/28/2014 |
11/12/2015 |
Dismissed |
No |
||
|
Level 3 Communications, LLC v. AIP Acquisition LLC |
10/8/2014 |
11/10/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Belden Inc. v. Berk-Tek LLC |
3/18/2014 |
11/5/2015 |
Affirmed in part, reversed in part |
No |
||
|
Apple Inc. v. Achates Reference Publishing |
6/2/2014 |
9/30/2015 |
Dismissed |
No |
||
|
Corning Inc. v. DSM IP Assets, B.V. |
8/12/2014 |
9/16/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Dynamic Drinkware, LLC v. National Graphics, Inc. |
9/12/2014 |
9/4/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Rackspace Holding v. Rotatable Technologies, LLC |
9/19/2014 |
08/14/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
SCHOTT Gemtron Corp. v. SSW Holding Company, Inc. |
8/20/2014 |
08/11/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Smith & Nephew, Inc. v. Convatec Technologies Inc. |
5/29/2014 |
08/10/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
EMC Corp. v. Personal Web Technologies, LLC |
IPR2013-00082 |
5/15/2014 |
08/10/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
|
|
Avaya Inc. v. Network-1 Security Solutions, Inc. |
5/22/2014 |
08/10/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Illumina, Inc. v. Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York |
3/6/2014 |
7/17/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
*Garmin International, Inc. v. Cuozzo Speed Technologies, LLC |
11/13/2013 |
7/8/2015 |
On rehearing: Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Microsoft Corp. v. Proxyconn, Inc. |
2/19/2014 |
6/16/2015 |
Affirmed in Part, |
No |
||
|
ScentAir Technologies, Inc. v. Prolitec, Inc. |
7/18/2014 |
06/09/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Syntroleum Corp. v. Neste Oil Oyj |
8/26/2014 |
06/08/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Handi Quilter and Tacony Corp. v. Bernina Int’l AG |
9/25/2014 |
06/05/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Schrader-Bridgeport Int’l, Inc. v. Continental Automotive Systems US, Inc. |
3/12/2014 |
06/05/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Berk-Tek, LLC v. Belden Inc. |
4/28/2014 |
4/17/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Nichia Corp. v. Emcore Corp. |
2/11/2014 |
4/16/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
St. Jude Medical, Cardiology Division, Inc. v. Volcano Corp. |
IPR2013-00258 |
No FWD |
4/14/2015 |
Denied |
No |
|
|
Munchkin, Inc. v. Luv N’Care, Ltd. |
4/21/2014 |
4/14/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Motorola Solutions, Inc. v. Mobile Scanning Technologies, LLC |
4/24/2014 |
4/13/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Micron Technology, Inc. v. The Board of Trustees of The University of Illinois |
3/10/2014 |
3/12/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
MicroStrategy Inc. v. Zillow, Inc. |
3/27/2014 |
3/12/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
LKQ Corp. v. Clearlamp, LLC |
3/27/2014 |
2/18/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Kyocera Corp. v. SoftView LLC |
3/27/2014 |
2/09/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
*Garmin International, Inc. v. Cuozzo Speed Technologies, LLC |
11/13/2013 |
2/4/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Epson America, Inc. v. Cascades Projection LLC |
*Designated as precedential