AIA BLOG
CBM FWD - Appealed
As the body of case law develops around AIA PTAB trials, Final Written Decisions (FWDs) that have been considered on appeal will be instructive for developing case strategies. Covered business method patent cases for which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) has rendered a decision are listed below with links to the FWD and the CAFC decision. For decisions that Finnegan has summarized for the Federal Circuit IP Blog, the PTAB case name is linked to the summary.
|
PTAB CASE NAME |
PTAB CASE NUMBER(S) |
FWD DATE |
CAFC CASE NUMBER(S) |
CAFC DECISION DATE |
CAFC DECISION |
RULE 36 |
|
Electronic Frontier Foundation v. Personal Audio, LLC |
10/4/2014 |
8/7/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Homeland Housewares, LLC v. Whirlpool Corp. |
10/21/2015 |
8/4/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Mitchell International, Inc. v. Audatex North America, Inc. |
2/19/2016 |
7/27/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Square, Inc. v. Think Computer Corp. |
11/27/2015 |
7/24/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Motionpoint Corp. v. Transperfect Global, Inc. |
7/15/2015 |
7/12/2017 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Viglink, Inc., Skimlinks, Inc., Skimbit, Ltd. v. Linkgine, Inc.Travelers Lloyds of Texas Insurance Co., The Travelers Indemnity Co. v. Integrated Claims Systems, LLC |
3/16/2016 3/30/2016 |
5/11/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Travelers Lloyds of Texas Insurance Co., The Travelers Indemnity Co. v. Integrated Claims Systems, LLC |
3/30/2016 |
4/11/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
FFF Enterprises, Inc. v. Amerisourcebergen Specialty Group, Inc. |
1/28/2016 |
4/6/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Carecloud Corp. v. Athenahealth, Inc. |
11/18/2015 |
3/10/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
PNC Bank N.A., U.S. Bank N.A., U.S. Bancorp, Bank of the West, Santander Bank, N.A., Ally Financial, Inc., Raymond James & Associates, Inc., Trustmark National Bank, Nationwie Bank, Synchrony Bank, General Electric Co., Commerce Bank, Cadence Bank N.A. v. Secure Axcess, LLC |
9/8/2015 |
2/21/2017 |
Reversed in part, vacated in part |
No |
||
|
MoneyCat Ltd. v. eBay Inc. [rule 36 judgment] |
9/23/2015 |
16-1399 |
1/18/2017 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
|
|
Apple, Inc., Domino’s Pizza, Inc., Domino’s Pizza, LLC, Fandango, LLC, Opentable, Inc. v. Ameranth, Inc. Agilysys, Inc. v. Ameranth, Inc. |
3/20/2015 |
11/29/2016 |
Affirmed in part; Reversed in part |
No |
||
|
Agilysys, Inc. v. Ameranth, Inc. |
4/6/2015 |
11/21/2016 |
Vacated, Remanded |
No |
||
|
Google Inc. v. Unwired Planet, LLC |
CBM2014-00005 |
3/30/2015 |
15-1810 |
11/15/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
|
Google Inc. v. Unwired Planet, LLC |
3/30/2015 |
11/15/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Fidelity National Information Services, Inc. v. Datatreasury Corp. |
4/29/2015 |
10/13/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Jack Henry and Associates, Inc. v. Datatreasury Corp. |
7/8/2015 |
10/13/2016 |
Denied as moot |
No |
||
|
Fiserv, Inc. v. Datatreasury Corp. |
9/1/2015 |
10/13/2016 |
Denied as moot |
No |
||
|
Hulu, LLC v. Intertainer, Inc. |
6/12/2015 |
9/26/2016 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Cambridge Associates, LLC v. Capital Dynamics |
8/31/2015 |
9/9/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
U.S. Bancorp v. Solutran, Inc. |
8/5/2015 |
8/8/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
International Securities Exchange, LLC v. Chicago Board Options Exchange, Inc. |
3/2/2015 |
3/25/2016 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
Blue Calypso, LLC v. Groupon, Inc. |
CBM2013-00033 |
12/17/2014 |
3/1/2016 |
Affirmed-in-part Reversed-in-part |
No |
|
|
Apple Inc. v. SightSound Technologies, LLC |
10/7/2015 |
12/15/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. v. Progressive Casualty Ins. Co. |
CBM2012-00002 |
1/23/2014 2/11/2014 3/13/2014 |
8/24/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
|
|
US Bancorp v. Retirement Capital Access Management Company LLC |
8/22/2014 |
8/7/2015 |
Affirmed |
Yes |
||
|
SAP America, Inc., v. Versata Development Group, Inc. |
6/11/2013 |
7/9/2015 |
Affirmed |
No |
||
|
GTNX, Inc. v. Inttra, Inc. |
CBM2014-00072 |
No FWD |
6/16/2015 |
Denied |
No |